H A&S 222a: Introduction to Energy and Environment (Life Under the Pale Sun)
this page from Spring 2006; next offered Spring 2007

Instructor: P.B. Rhines, Prof. of Oceanography and Atmospheric Sciences, Rhines@ocean.washington.edu
TA: Clara Fuchsman, graduate student in chemical oceanography, cfuchsm1@u.washington.edu


Click here for a printable, legible PDF file of the course announcment.

group with solar cookers image of Hurricane Bonnie

Basic Info
Assignments
Other useful stuff
Instructors
Essay guidelines/resources/suggestions..see also library
News Kiosk
Times and locations
Reading assignments
Links and Public Lectures
Syllabus
Lab demonstrations info
Grading policy
Textbooks Essay, Problem Set, Discussion item assignments
Other handouts
Student Questionnaire
Quiz schedule
Listen
Calendar
Lecture notes, lecture slides, quizzes and other posted notes
Library and Web search tutorials




News Kiosk

Week 10 The course summary just posted refers to chapter 1 of Lomborg which you do not have ('The Litany'); posted below (next to Lectures) is that chapter (sorry, it's a big file, clumsy scan).

An upgraded version of the Week 9 lectures (called Lecture 11) with quite a lot of descriptive text added, is now posted under Lectures. The handed-out Review Problems and handed-out A Review of the Course is also posted there. While this certainly does not include all the important material, it summarizes a lot of the courses objectives and techniques.

Week 9 Posted below is the Tues lecture, a separate discussion of exponential growth and global population curves, the essay-3 assignment and the reading assignment for this week, including a .pdf of a summary article for the arguments in Hawkens & Lovins' Natural Capitalism. Also, because Thomas Friedman's The Earth is Flat and a counter argument about the 'Spiky Earth' was discussed there are two .pdf's posted about Friedman's ideas.


See Al Gore's new movie, soon in a theater near you:


Visit Zeri.org....Zero Emissions Research & Initiatives, www.zeri.org and learn about bamboo houses built from sustainable forestry in Columbia and Costa Rica.


Week 8 Next week we will be reading Natural Capitalism by Hawken, Lovins and Lovins. You can download chapters from www.rmi.org (search the site for this title). I recommend listening to Amory Lovins lecture: you can hear one archived on KUOW by going to their website: go to
www.kuow.org and search on 'Lovins'. Note, use the RealPlayer option as the MP3 option has the wrong lecture archived.
The Thursday lecture on the ozone hole and alternative energy sources (solar, wind) is posted below.

Clara gave a Tuesday lecture on the carbon cycle, following the production by photosynthesis of biomass carbon (from atmospheric CO2 and nutrients, energized by sunlight) up the food chain. The ocean receives the vast majority of carbon and is an enormous store of it. Increasing amounts of CO2 entering the ocean will make it more acidic, possibly causing calcium carbonate shells and exo-skeletons to suffer. Both her lecture slides and summary notes are now posted below (Lecture 7B). The 2d hour discussion of global energy and oil is posted below (Lecture 9), as is the Problem Set 3, due Tues 23 May. The Arctic warming problem was handed back...well done everyone!

Week 7 We are entering the final phase of the course, where we look at global energy and environment. The big topics are 'the end of oil', global energy use and pollution of air, water and land. To approach this huge subject we describe the atmosphere and its circulation, then debate over air pollution (McNeill and Lomborg...see reading assignment). Finally we do the numbers for our global fossil fuel energy use and discuss its future..and ours. Our tactic is to continue to use the 'lens' of energy to look at these problems, both natural energy cycling and human energy use.

Last week's Thursday lecture was Clara on photosynthesis and you have handed in a spectulative homework problem on the effects of global warming on the Arctic ecosystem. This is real science by the way, and it is really happening. Forlorn polar bears have become a 'poster child' for global warming, but the effects run far deeper. We are talking about some of the most extensive and intense parts of the global ecosystem, the 'lungs of the Earth'. If we had time we would read about Gaia, James Lovelock's conception of the Earth as a living, sentient being, or at very least a system which regulates its own temperature unknowlingly, through biological processes. Compare us with Venus and Mars and you see the difference between a healthy (in the eyes of living things) planet and a dead planet.

I have posted Clara's lecture 7 and problem assignment, and this Tuesday's (May 9) lecture 8 on the circulation of the atmosphere...the 'atmospheric heat engine'. Thursday (May 11) is a discussion/debate on two views of atmospheric pollution: J.R. McNeill's and Bjorn Lomborg's.

Week 6
I am off to give a lecture at University of Reading, England. Clara talks on photosynthesis on Thursday. Last night I went to a pre-premiere showing of former Vice President Al Gore's movie, Inconvenient Truth, about global warming. It is exciting to see that, after being elected President but denied that job by the Supreme Court, Gore has taken on this mission. He was present and talked with great passion about the probems and solutions relating to the global environment. The movie will be in theaters on 2 June. If you can go please do...as Gore says, the first weekend's attendence will determine whether the film 'makes it' into lots of other theaters or not.

We are lucky in Washington State to have Gov Gregoire, Mayor Nickels and King County Exec. Sims all leading an activist movement for a greener world. They all spoke at this event, and were very impresive. Tune in to what they are saying.

Week 5

We have posted a 9-page review of the science core and some review problems, both for the midterm quiz, click on 'Lecture notes....'. Also a handout giving lots of energy-numbers relevant to global environment. Also last year's mid-term quiz.

This week's reading is listed below too.

The PCC Annual lecture on global warming and energy strategies by Prof. Steven Pacala of Princeton University, given at UW this week, was very relevant to the course. You can't hear it again, but you can come close by listening to Pacala's interview on Seattle Weekday, on KUOW: the link is: here.

The Arctic Climate Impact Reassessment is a major study of the effect of climate generally and global warming in particular on the Arctic...people, ecosystems, and the physical ocean, atmosphere and land surface. Unique properties of the Arctic, like its permafrost, are under great threat of change. This fine thousand page report (2004) is all available as .pdf's of chapters at www.acia.uaf.edu; to read a compact summary paper with wonderful graphics, go to amap.no/acia/ and click on 'ACIA Highligthts'.

When Louise Richards from the Oceans library talked to us on web searching, one of the things we homed in is a report, The Earth is Faster Now, Indigenous Observations of Arctic Environmental Change, edited by Krupnik and Jolly, put out by the Arctic Research Consortium of the US (ARCUS). It is very interesting to hear about the native relationship with climate and its change, in their own words. The introduction is available as a .pdf at the ARCUS website.

Week 4

Important Lecture Alert!Monday 24 April 2006 at UW's Kane Hall: PCC ANNUAL PUBLIC LECTURE - Prof. Stephen Pacala, Princeton Univ, "Solving the carbon and climate problem with technology available today," 7:00pm, 120 Kane.

20 April...some do over problems are posted below.

18 April 2006
We had a request to put announcements for important public lectures relevant to this course; guess what, there's one tomorrow morning! It is an exciting series of video seminars where the audience is global...members of the World Univeristies Network. The early morning time in Seattle is so that people in Norway and UK haven't gone off to the pub yet.
WORLD UNIVERSITIES NETWORK VIDEO SEMINAR - Dr Klaus Keller, Pennsylvania State Univ, "Abrupt climate change: Would we see it coming?", 9:00am, Weds. 19 April 2006, T-239 HSB. This room is on the lowest level of Health Sciences, near the South Campus Center.

We handed out excerpts from Harald Sverdrup's Among the Tundra People, which tells of his winters living with the nomadic Arctic natives of north-eastern Asia. In 1917 he joined Roald Amundson on the ship Maud, in the Arctic ocean near the Chukchi Coast. The goal was to reach the North Pole, but Sverdrup ended up living with the natives through long winters when the ship was frozen in the sea-ice. His journals tell of people who had barely encountered Europeans, and gives a glimpse of their lives. These natives, like those of central Canada, were very dependent on caribou, and less on the sea, for food.

Several new postings: Louise Richards' hints on how to find full-text articles from Tuesday NY Times ('Science Times'), a good source of news on climate and environment (click on Library and Web...above).

Clara's lecture on chemical bonding is posted under Lectures. The discussion/debate assignment is also posted.

Under the new button above called Links and Lectures we will list events...evening lectures etc., which occur, and more resources for researching essays, like the World Watch Institute described in class. Lester Brown is the champion of this organization which publishes 'State of the World' books every year. Visit www.worldwatch.org where there are many free downloads of interest, including back issues of State of the World and the monthly WWI magazine. Brown was the author of the book Who Will Feed China which back in 1995 called attention to China's rapidly growing footprint on the global enviroment. A truckload of corn and a hungry cow in Somalia, from the WWI magazine, is shown below.

Week 3
13 April 2006
Solutions for the first set of problems are posted below (under Essays and Problem Set Assignments)
12 April 2006 Maps...a good thing to spend some time with. We have mentioned the official Canadian website for maps, atlas.gc.ca. Visit also Athropolis, "a web site of all things cold, icy and Arctic".

11 April 2006 Today's web-searching lecture by Louise Richards of the Ocean and Fisheries Library gives us a lot of insight into literature about Arctic and environment. UW has an enormous number of electronic journals, and of traditional books, atlases and journals. The Arctic and Geobase databases turned up much of interest. It is good to see Knud Rasmussen's original works on his Thule expeditions available (translated into English). It is very challenging to use the Web creatively: the vast amount of information requires discipline for it to be used well. The worst aspect is that we can copy relevant-looking paragraphs relating to our work without either understanding them fully, or assessing their quality.

Free film: Saturday 8 April 6.00/7.30 pm
Ethnic Culture Center UW and UW Canadian Studies Center present
An Evening with Canadian 1st Nation Filmmakers


Two Worlds Colliding, by Tasha Hubbard
It's a bonechilling -20C when Aboriginal man Darell Night finds himself dumped on the city outskirts by police. Night survives, but is stunned to hear that the frozen body of an Aboriginal man has been discovered in the same remote area. The film chronicles the painful story of Saskatoon's infamous 'freezing deaths' and the schism between a fearful, mistrustful Aboriginal community and a police force that must come to terms with a shocking secret. This is recent history, and responsibility for these deaths is still largely unresolved.

Urban Inuk with director Jobie Weetaluktuk
This gripping story follows the lives of three Inuit in Montreal over the course of one hot and humid summer. Through their stories, the film explores the 'urbanization' of the Inuit psyche, as Inuit move farther and farther from a direct connection to the land that has sustained their culture for thousands of years. Scenes of their Arctic origins in the village of Igloolik contrast the streets of Montreal and their attempt to recover a sense of community there.
Reception at 6.00-7.00 in ECC lobby, film screening at 7.30 in ECC Theater, 3940 Brooklyn Ave., UW. Visit ECC.

Visit Igloolik.

More generally, visit the Atlas of Canada and look at maps of the physical environment, the distribution of villages and people. The adjacent picture shows the projected change in mean wintertime temperature for the period 2080-2100, compared with 1975-1995.

The red color refers to +9C (+16 degrees F), while black is greater than +25C, and yellow is 4 to 5C warmer temperatures. These numbers are big!

return to top


7 iv 2006 The news about the melting of Greenland's icecap and the shrinkage of the Antarctic ice sheet is very intense. A good review of this is in Science magazine, by their writer Dick Kerr, at http://www.sciencemag.org/cgi/reprint/311/5768/1698.pdf

Tom Toles cartoon from the Washington Post

To access important research journals while at UW go to the UW website, click on Libraries, then click on E-Journals. For Science magazine, then click on 'S' and scroll until you see Science (Highwire) 10/01/1995-present (there are many journal titles including the word 'science'). Once there, usually you will got to Previous Issues, and search on the author name or topic. For example, for this topic, go to Advanced Search and search on Greenland ice (Words in the title or abstract) and delimit the dates to 2006.

6 iv 2006 We looked in more detail at Time Magazine (3 iv 06 issue), which describe Seattle's Mayor, Greg Nickels, and leading a group of 218 mayors from 39 states in pledging to reduce CO2 emissions...if the federal government won't do it 'top down' let's do it 'bottom up'. Wal-Mart pledges to make their stores greener, and the world's largest carpet manufacturer works to 'climb Mt. Sustainability', that is to make his company have zero footprint on the ecology of the planet. We want to learn about Seattle's environmentally friendly buses too.

Greenland is melting, at least during the past 10 years. The figures below from Science Magazine (24 March 2006, by Ekstrom, Nettles and Tsai), show that small earthquakes, the rumbling of the glaciers as they scrape seaward over bed-rock, has become much louder. The glaciers have accelerated their flow by a factor of 2 to 3 since early 1990s. The GRACE satellites can actually weigh the ice mass from outer space and are showing several tens of cubic km of ice loss per year. In Antarctica the same satellites indicate 148 cubic km of ice loss from Greenland each year. These two sources provide a significant fraction (almost half) of the global rise in sea level.



1 iv 2006
Ian Joughin of Polar Sciences Center, UW shows this figure of the retreat of the Jakobshavn Glacier in Greenland. Note the curves and dots showing the air temperature variation from 1880 to 2000+ which are very unusual: in the Arctic and particularly northern Atlantic region, there was a strong warming in the 1920s-1930s followed by slow cooling until the 1980s when warming took over again. The earlier warming is not well understood.

The past few weeks have seen frequent news releases on the melting of polar ice. Greenland particularly is in the news, as its outflowing glaciers have accelerated in the past few years: flowing fast enough that you can see them move if you are standing next to one. Visit ABC News at this link

Using new orbiting satellites in the 'GRACE' mission, which sense small changes in Earth's gravity caused by ice changes, the melting of the Antarctic ice sheets has been observed over the past 3 years.

Last week's Time Magazine has a major cover story on global warming, showing a distraught polar bear on the cover. If you are clever enough to figure out their website, you can read it here.

Upsala glacier in Andes Mountains of Argentina in 1928 (above) and 2004 (below). The glacier is retreating about 60m per year.





4 iv 2006 I have posted material from the first and second weeks including the course syllabus and logistics, and Problem Set 1. In the .pdf there are minor typos corrected in red. These problems are due Tues 11 April in class. If you have questions email or phone me or Clara; note that she has a 'one' in her address, cfuchsm1@u.washington.edu, not an 'ell'.

posted Thurs 30iii06. Today we heard the beginning of The End of Nature by Bill McKibben, in which he argues that we imagine changes of the environment to occur very slowly, at the pace of mountains eroding and continents drifting, but we are wrong....in the sense that human civilization spans only 330 generations or so (10 or 12 thousand years). There are some trees that are that old (not species, but individual trees)! Rapid change has always been part of life--individual life or the life of a village or country--but now we are experiencing rapid change of the entire planet, and what he terms 'the end of Nature'.

"By the end of nature I do not mean the end of the world. The rain will still fall and the sun shine, though differently than before. When I say "nature," I mean a certain set of human ideas about the world and our place in it. But the death of those ideas begins with concrete changes in the reality around us--changes that scientists can measure and enumerate. More and more frequently, these changes will clash with our perceptions, until, finally, our sense of nature as eternal and separate is washed away, and we will see all too clearly what we have done."--McKibben, The End of Nature, Anchor Books, 1989.


return to top

Links and Public Lectures

There is a huge number of resources on the web for environment and energy. We will develop an annotated list here. A couple to start:

Links
Public lectures return to top

This course was first offered in Fall 2004. To visit the 2004 working website, click here.


"The world looks so different after learning science. For example, trees are made of air, primarily. When they are burned, they go back to air, and in the flaming heat is released the flaming heat of the sun which was bound in to convert the air into tree. And in the ash is the small remnant of the part which did not come from air, that came from the solid Earth, instead.
These are beautiful things, and the content of science is wonderfully full of them. They are inspiring and they can be used to inspire others."
-- Richard Feynmann, physicist, California Inst. of Technology.

"We need a Manhatten Project for energy independence in the US." -- Dennis O'Brien, University of Oklahoma.

"We are living our lives as energy hunter-gatherers rather than energy farmers. The midwest is farmland for windpower and biomass; the southern states and California are farmlands for solar energy." -- Dan Kammen, Renewable and Appropriate Energy Laboratory, Univ. of California, Berkeley, on Talk of the Nation, Science Friday, 13 September 2002.

To this we should add: The World-wide Web marks the end of our 'hunter-gatherer' stage in dealing with information. Its effect on students and teachers is enormous. Having an ever increasing proportion of human knowledge at our finger-tips, it is possible to 'write' an essay on almost anything with a few cut-and-paste operations. Properly quoted and cited, this is fair enough, but what, now, does creativity mean, what is learning, and what should be our task as students and teachers? I believe we must make the best of this by moving on: solve problems, get out into the field, apply this huge information resource but do not be fooled into giving up your own, individual creative thought. Peter Rhines, 1iv2006



You may be also interested to browse a description for a previous course which is related to this one...yet was largely carried out with hands-on laboratory experiments. It may be offered in late 2006/early 2007 if there is demand.

Course poster: click image for readable copy.
Also visit our lab (Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory) here.


Wind power--- Three vertical-axis wind power generators at Gorgornio Pass near Palm Springs in the California desert. Each small tower generates about 25 kilowatts, or 50,000 kilowatt hours per year (for average 15 mph winds). www.windharvest.com

Click on the image for a larger one.


Hurricane Bonnie, 1998
Storms large and small:
A laboratory experiment below shows the intensification of winds as fluid is drawn into the center of a vortex. It gives us both a concrete example of some of the things going on inside tornados and hurricanes.

Hurricanes and their counterparts in the Indian Ocean (tropical cyclones) cause great financial loss in the US and great loss of life in the underdeveloped world. Patterns of global climate change affect hurricanes greatly, an example of the complexity of the environment. For example when el Nino is strongly active in the tropical Pacific, Atlantic hurricanes tend to disappear. The energy source for these whirling storms is the heat of the tropical ocean. In a warmer world these storms may become more intense.

Does the science of hurricanes matter? Obviously, satellite images help us prepare for them, and it costs about $1 million per mile of coastline to evacuate in anticipation of a storm, so prediction of the path of the hurricane is valuable. Loss of life in Bangladesh is enormous; the low-lying land is unusually prone to experience these storms (and vulnerable to them). Yet some economists argue that public health countermeasures following the storm, and rebuilding of jobs and infrastructure is more important than avoiding the immediate destruction by the storm.
water tornado in tank


Solar cookers are helping to reduce dependence on firewood for fuel in many countries; cooking and purification of water is carried out in units constructed very simply. This is an example of a soft technology, which we can replicate in the lab, and study its efficiency. Building a solar cooker project is an interesting blend of science, engineering and common sense. Go to this website and inspect the designs there (click on captions beneath the illustrations for more complete descriptions). image from http://www.solarcooking.org


MOVIE below shows our experiment, a vertical slice of Cape Cod's sandy soil). This fresh water flows down from the surface, outward toward the ocean, and floats on top of salty ocean water (dark green, at the right), which invades the sand as a wedge (light blue) from the side. In times of drought the salt water moves higher and infiltrates wells. The lab experiment below shows a side view cutting through the coast, with red dots marking the movement of the tan-colored freshwater layer, outward above the blue ocean water. The dark region is the ocean itself.

In this course we will observe some of these processes, while investigating local and global aspects of fresh water supplies. About 40% of the cattle in the US once drank from underground water supplies from the High Plains aquifer, an underground 'river' that extends from Texas to North Dakota. Irrigation using this source peaked in the early 1980s, and has had to decline as the aquifer is depleted. Half the accessible water was gone by 1993, and it will be exhausted in the next 25 years or so.

There is some evidence that fresh water is moving through the global system more rapidly, because of global warming. This means more evaporation of ocean water in the tropics, more rainfall middle latitudes. Paradoxically, droughts can increase as well because climate change is full of patterns...it is not just a uniform warming or cooling of the Earth.


Click on the image to see the animation of a lab experiment illustrating the flow of ground water (made visible by red dots) toward the sea in a sandy coastal zone like Cape Cod.

Instructor:

Peter.Rhines
Ocean Sciences Bldg. 319
tel: 543-0593
rhines@ocean.washington.edu
Office hours: by arrangement

Teaching Assistant:

Clara Fuchsman (2006)
School of Oceanography cfuchsml@u.washington.edu

return to top

Syllabus here.


Discussion of lab demonstrations here.


Reading assignment - Week 1:
McNeill
Preface xxi-xxvi, Chap. 1: 3-21
Harte: Ch. 1: 1-14
Diamond 1-23

Week 2:
Ehrlich, This Cold Heaven: Preface xi-xv, Chap. 1: 3-33
McNeill: Chapter 11 (Fuels, Tools and Economics)

Week 3:
Ehrlich, 118-138, 197-220, 247-258 (Knud Rassmusson's 5th Thule expedition).
Harte, p 65-73 (Thermodynamics and Energy Transfer)
p 23-27 (beginning of Steady-State Box Models and Residence Times)

Week 4:
Sverdrup, Among the Tundra People 118-138, 197-220, 247-258
Harte, continue last week's p 65-73 (Thermodynamics and Energy Transfer) then p 74-78 (climbing on a liter of milk), 158-168 (climatology.. ...don't worry about all the inner detail)

Week 5: Mowatt, People of the Deer

Week 6:
McNeill, Chapters 3 and 4 ('The Atmosphere')

Week 7:
Lomborg
Skeptical Environmentalist, Chapters 15 and 16 ('Air Pollution','Acid Rain')

Week 8:
Lomborg,
Chapter 11 ('Energy')
Roberts, The End of Oil, Prologue and Chapter 2 ('The last of easy oil')

Weeks 9-10:
Lovins & Hawken
Natural Capitalism: Summary article (Harvard Business Review 1999)
For the following go to www.natcap.org and read online or download individual chapters (the real home page is www.rmi.org, the Rocky Mountain Institute in Colorado).
Preface
chapter 1 (The Next Industrial Revolution 1-21)
chapter 3 (Waste Not 48-61)
chapter 14 (Human Capitalism 285-308)


return to top


Lectures, quizzes and other handouts:
(note that all these files are Acrobat .pdf files unless otherwise specified - get Acrobat reader here)


Course logistics pdf here 28 March 2006

Lecture 1: slides (28 March 2006). 1.3 Mb pdf file annotated slides here.

Lecture 2: text (30 March - 4 April)

Orders of magnitude named, from picometers to teragrams and some physical constants of the environment associated with them.

Lecture 3: text (Thurs 6 April - 11 April; a new figure is appended at end of this lecture)

Lecture 4: figs (Tues 11 April)

Lecture 5: chemical bonds (Tues 18 April)

Lecture 6: The Sun's radiation meets Earth's Greenhouse
phase change and water

(coming soon..some of this material is in the review notes)

Lecture 7A: Photosynthesis-slides (Thurs 4 May)

Lecture 7A: Photosynthesis-outline

Lecture 7B: Carbon Cycle-slides (Tues 16 May)

Lecture 7B: Carbon Cycle-outline

Lecture 8: Air: the atmosphere (Tues 9 May) This .pdf is expanded a bit from the paper handout, with more figures (and color!).

Lecture 9: Global energy, the 'end of oil'...(Tues 16 May)

Lecture 10: Global energy, the ozone hole and two alternative energy sources: solar and wind...(Thurs 18 May)

Lecture 11: upgraded with more text. Global energy, population growth, Natural Capitalism(Tues 23 May/Thurs 25 May)

Review of the Course (Mon 29 May 06)

Review problems (Thurs 25 May)

Lomborg Ch.1(Tues 30 May 2006)

Lovins & Hawken summary article (from 1999 Harvard Business Review) (23v2006).
Friedman interview- The World is Flat (23v2006)
Friedman New York Times book review The World is Flat (23v2006)
Notes on exponential growth/global population (23v2006)

midterm quiz review problems-1 (Tues 25 April)

midterm review of science core (Tues 25 April)

Energy numbers: a handout describing lots of useful statistics relating to global energy (Tues 25 April)

mid-term quiz from last year's class. (Weds 26 April)


mid-term quiz (Tues 2 May)


return to top


Times and Locations:

Lectures: Mary Gates Hall room 242
Tuesday and Thursday 10.30am-12.20pm

Grading policy:

Essay homework: 50%, class participation: 25%, quizzes and exam: 25%.

Textbooks:
Something New Under the Sun: an Environmental History of the Twentieth-Century World,
by J.R. McNeill, W.W. Norton Co., NY, 2000.
There will also be a course-pak with readings from other sources.

Recommended reading:
Natural Capitalism: Creating the Next Industrial Revolution,
by Paul Hawken, Amory Lovins, L. Hunter Lovins; Rocky Mountain Institute, Colorado,

Consider a Spherical Cow by John Harte, University Science Books., NY, 1988.

This Cold Heaven: Seven Seasons in Greenland,
by Gretel Ehrlich, Vintage Books 2003.





return to top

Essays, Debate/discussions and Problem Sets